Decadent Desserts on Anna Maria Island

| February 4, 2023

In previous articles, we’ve talked about where to go grocery shopping, some places to have great meals or just a good cup of coffee. All of those are important, but sometimes, what we need is a dessert. And not just any dessert, but something special. Whether it’s for a birthday, other special occasions or just to satisfy a craving, here are a few places we love to get desserts on Anna Maria Island.

Hometown Desserts

Just like the name implies, Hometown Desserts is from right here in Anna Maria. What started as a home-based business in 2007 is now 2 locations. The original is right here in Anna Maria, on Pine Avenue, and the second is in Bradenton. Not only do they make the cakes, pies and cookies you would expect to see, but they also offer cheesecake and cupcake options. With choices ranging from a traditional red velvet cake to Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie, there is no shortage of options to make your dessert memorable. Goods from Hometown Desserts may be found at many local restaurants and many of their creations can be customized for your event. Check out their website for more information. They are located at 507 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216

The Cheesecake Cutie & Café

Opening in 2019, Cheesecake Cutie is one of the newer options for desserts on anna maria island. But their roots go back much further. The center of Cheesecake Cutie is the original recipe belonging to the owner’s mother. Just like the name indicates, cheesecake is the centerpiece of their menu. Options for full-size cheesecakes range from original to a Nutella-based variation called Tall Dark & Handsome. The bakery also offers gluten-free and a Keto variety of their cheesecakes. Another popular pick is their Cuties. These are individual-serving cheesecakes that are available for parties or events. Cuties even have a vegan option. The café is located at 3324 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Visit their website for more information.

Breezy Bakery

At first glance, Breezy Bakery seems like more of a traditional bakery. Their early morning baking produces fresh bread, muffins, scones and their popular cinnamon rolls. But if you look further, you will find the bakery has plenty of cake and pie options to satisfy that sweet tooth. This family-owned local business is located at  11904 Cortez Road West Unit A, Cortez, Florida 34215. Their menu includes sugar-free, dairy-free, gluten-free and vegan items. Visit their website for more information.


Don’t sleep on Publix. The chain grocery store you may find yourself shopping in for many grocery items also has a bakery that offers both pre-made and custom options. From pies to full wedding cakes, their bakery has a dizzying number of options. They can be a particularly good choice for kids’ birthday cakes. The Publix on Anna Maria Island is located at 3900 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Visit the bakery website to see all the options available.

Finding desserts on Anna Maria Island isn’t difficult. These are just a few of our favorites. If you are staying in, or planning a stay in one of our luxury vacation homes and want more options, our local experts are ready to help you. Just contact us and we will get to work on making sure your event or dinner is exactly what you want it to be.

Recent Stories.

Emergency Contacts for Your Stay On AMI

It is entirely understandable to not want to think about the worst-case scenario, especially when on vacation or trying to relax. Nothing will leave you feeling more helpless than not being prepared ...
Read More

Monthly AMI Events | ’24 Summer Edition 

Getting ready for your summer getaway to Anna Maria Island? The hottest season has some of the coolest events on the island! We have put together a list of some ...
Read More
theme park couple

Get Ready for Adventure! Theme Parks Near Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island is home to wonderful museums & markets, delicious dining, and so much more. But if you are looking to add a little bit of magic during your ...
Read More

Be the First to Know

Sign up for our Newsletter and be the first to know about our updates and promotions.

We’ll make sure your next vacation is relaxing and fun!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.