The Best Bakeries on AMI

Imagine it with me: you wake up early to take in the beautiful ocean views from the comfort of your luxurious vacation rental, do your morning stretches, or join in for a sunrise yoga session. You’ve got your morning cup of coffee from one of the island’s best coffee houses, and you realize that nothing could make the world more perfect at that moment. Well, almost nothing. Any situation in life can be improved with a delicious handcrafted pastry or baked good. Good thing for you: Anna Maria Island is home to some of the best bakeries to delight your loved ones and tastebuds! We have put together this guide so you don’t miss out. 

Hometown Desserts

_{507 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216} 

Hours

• Mon-Fri 10am-4pm 
• Saturday 10am- 5pm

Hometown Desserts has won multiple awards on the island, including “Best Key Lime Pie” and “Favorite Bakery”, and it is easy to see why. This adorable bakery started as a home business in 2007, opened its first storefront in 2012, and expanded into its second location (just a short drive to the mainland in Bradenton) in 2016. Owner Cindy Tutterow uses inspiration from family recipes to create an extensive menu of cakes, pies, cookies, and scones! And for those who prefer something a little more savory, Hometown has you covered with various quiches. Custom cakes are available for special occasions as well. But if you want something truly special, get yourself the Coconut Key Lime Cake, you will thank us later. 

A special thank you to Hometown Desserts for letting us use their photos for this blog!

Jinnie & Jane E’s Cafe and Gift Shop

_{9807 Gulf Drive, Anna Maria FL 34216}

Hours

• Mon-Sun 7am-3pm

This groovy shop isn’t just for souvenirs and breakfast; Jinnie & Jane E’s Cafe and Gift Shop also features a bakecase that is truly out of sight. Featuring fresh gooey cinnamon rolls daily and a rotating menu of other baked goodies such as muffins, scones, and pies, you will want to make sure you stop by and ask what the treat of the day is! 

Anna Maria Bakehouse 

_{200 Gulf Drive North Bradenton Beach, FL 34217}

Hours

• Sun-Thurs: 11:30am – 9pm
• Fri-Sat: 11:30am – 10pm

If you are looking for the freshest, most delicious artisan bread, then Anna Maria Bakehouse is your go-to place. With a mouthwatering selection including ciabatta, focaccia, cuban loaf, micha, and our personal favorite, the olive ciabatta bun, your sandwiches and tea times will be taken to the next level. And don’t forget the buttery, flaky, crisp croissants- a true delight! Their breads are baked fresh daily, ensuring the highest quality and taste. 

Still want something sweet? This scratch-artisan bakery also offers a handful of housemade, no additives included, sweets that will surely delight. Offerings are seasonal and can include: 

• Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Oatmeal Rasin Cookies
• Peanutbutter Cookies
• Sugar Cookies
• Rice Crispy Treats
• Triple Chocolate
• Coconut Cake
• Chocolate Peanutbutter Cake
• Key Lime Pie
• And more! 

Bonus: Farmers Market Tent
101 North Bay Blvd. Anna Maria, FL 34216
October – May
Every Tuesday from 8:30am – 2pm
Out and about and looking for something extra fun to do in the community? 
Get some fantastic treats while visiting the farmers’ market with a curated selection of Anna Maria Bakehouse goodies, baked fresh just for the market! 

The Donut Experiment 

_{210c Pine Ace, Anna Maria, FL 34216}

Hours

• Sun-Sat 7am – 1pm 

Do you want your baked goodie to be a little more interactive? Get ready to test your sweet, sweet creativity at The Donut Experiment. Fresh cake donuts are made daily and are used as a base for your custom donut delight! Get your donut, pick your icing, and add your favorite toppings to make a donut that is truly you. 

Icing options include: 

• Chocolate
• Caramel
• Maple
• Vanilla
• Glaze

Topping options include: 

• Rainbow sprinkles
• Chocolate sprinkles
• Peanuts
• Coconut
• Graham Cracker
• Oreo
• Bacon (You read that right!) 
• Fruity Pebbles
• Reese’s Pieces
• Candy Bar
• Chocolate Chips
• M&Ms
• Sea Salt
• CinnamonSugar
• Powdered sugar

Don’t forget to ask about unique seasonal options!

Too many options? They have recipes and suggestions ready to go! 

The Island Donut Company

_{103 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217}

Hours:

• Sun – Thur 8am-9pm
• Fri – Sat 8am – 10pm 

For a more traditional (and no less delicious) donut experience, the Island Donut Company has you covered. Traditional raised donuts, cake donuts, donut holes, twists, and absolutely massive apple fritters– they have it all! Are you feeling a little less sweet? They also have offerings in the form of bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and lunch sandwich boxes! 

*We know that finding good gluten-free baked goods can be nearly impossible, but The IDC offers customizable options for people with many different food allergies and sensitivities to ensure that everyone gets to enjoy a nice treat no matter what their limitations might be. 

The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe

_{3324 E. Bay Drive, Holmes Beach, FL 34217}

Hours

• Monday, Friday & Saturday 6:00am-8:00pm
• Tuesday – Thursday 6:00am-3:00pm

Handcrafted from gourmet family recipes, The Cheesecake Cutie is an absolute must-visit for anyone who likes cheesecakes. The extensive menu of flavors is sure to have you drooling. Want to try them all? The Cuties, individual-sized portions of delectable deliciousness, are the star of the show. Try all the flavors without the commitment to an entire cake. 

Flavors include: 

• Original
• Blueberry Lemon
• Butterfinger
• Chai Latte
• Chocolate Chip
• Chocolate Delight
• Cookie Butter
• Key Lime
• Oreo
• Kahlua Kiss
• Northern Crumb
• Oh, Hot Graham! Cold Brew
• Peanut Butter Dream
• Pineapple Coconut
• Turtle
• White Chocolate Raspberry
• …and more!

At The Cheesecake Cutie, inclusivity is key. With a wide range of flavors, including gluten-free, dairy-free, and sugar-free options, everyone can indulge in some cheesecake. Plus, many of these Cuties can be found at a number of favorite restaurants across the island! 

While the cheesecakes are the stars, The Cheesecake Cutie also offers a range of additional food options. From bagels to some of the best eggs, breakfast bowls, and oatmeals, this little cafe has something to satisfy every craving. You’ll be leaving The Cheesecake Cutie full and happy. 

With treats like these, it is worth planning a trip to Anna Maria Island just to do a food tour! Reach out today to the experts at Serendipity to start planning your getaway.